Skip to main content
yanco Home
Menu
  • Home
  • watch
  • magazine
  • calendar
  • index
  • Subscribe
Search Log in
  • nl
  • en
You are here
  • Home
  • Magazine
  • What Remains in Midair
Otolith 1 (The Otolith Group, 2003)
Otolith 1 (The Otolith Group, 2003)

What Remains in Midair

The Otolith Group’s Otolith I (2003)

article by
Arta Barzanji
20/20 Vision
16.11.2026

Two divers appear against an expanse of saturated blue, their lower bodies barely distinguishable. A light glows beneath them; the soundtrack turns hollow, aquatic. The voice falls silent. One diver plunges downwards; soon the narration resumes. As it declares, “I have lost my place in the world,” a wider shot reveals a structure beneath the swimmers. The words announce disorientation just as the image acquires coordinates. Soon comes a more immediate correspondence: “I have become a new mammal, born in a weightless sea, swimming in a new ocean.” The promise, and perhaps the limitation, of London-based collective The Otolith Group’s speculative film essay Otolith I (2003) resides in images briefly developing their own relations before the voice gathers them back into its account.

The film begins with a scientific report dated 2103. Sustained exposure to microgravity has transformed the human vestibular system; the resulting species can inhabit space but no longer withstand Earth’s gravity. “Earth is out of bounds for us now; it remains a planet accessible only through media.” From this imagined future, Dr Usha Adebaran-Sagar searches the records of her ancestors for the processes that brought her species into being. “For us, there is no memory without image and no image without memory,” she observes. But neither can recover what exceeds them: “That excess is the event. History.” She searches for “critical points,” “thresholds,” “moments of becoming”: how one possible future became her present.

Her inquiry is also a family history. The film is dedicated to Anasuya Gyan-Chand (1902–1995), the socialist and feminist grandmother of artist Anjalika Sagar. Gyan-Chand served as president of the National Federation of Indian Women. She met Valentina Tereshkova, the first woman in space, and understood her achievement in relation to the aspirations of the post-independence generation. “What lessons can Indian socialists learn from this?” she asked of the Soviet project; what of India’s own path, or China’s? The narrator remarks that these questions “remain in mid-air despite the promises.” The phrase joins two kinds of suspension: the bodily condition imagined by the film, and the political futures that earlier generations neither realised nor entirely relinquished. Recalled greetings and hands held keep a particular life from becoming merely its emblem.

The granddaughter’s own historical moment seems considerably less open. She joins the February 2003 demonstrations against the imminent invasion of Iraq, knowing, or believing, that the war will go ahead. The narrator calls the mobilisation “a protest for the right to protest,” as though its unprecedented scale could make the inevitable briefly possible to avert. Anjalika subsequently travels to Russia to experience microgravity. The flight that offers a new sense of bodily freedom is enabled by a military aircraft; the space programmes that once promised collective emancipation have been inseparable from geopolitical rivalry, weapons and commerce. The century of space exploration also produced the atomic bomb. Technological progress, then, neither guarantees political emancipation nor necessarily betrays its promise.

The space programmes that once promised collective emancipation have been inseparable from geopolitical rivalry, weapons, and commerce. The century of space exploration also produced the atomic bomb. Technological progress, then, neither guarantees political emancipation nor necessarily betrays its promise.

Arta Barzanji

One of the film’s more surprising temporal reversals comes with Ayi Kwei Armah’s The Beautyful Ones Are Not Yet Born (1968), a novel marked by the disappointed hopes of post-independence Ghana. The narrator hears its title as “a call put through to her future and my present, where we, the beautiful ones, live and work.” The beautiful ones have arrived, yet their bodily emancipation has made their ancestral planet uninhabitable. Has the promise been fulfilled, or transformed beyond recognition? Its science fiction holds both possibilities in view.

Its mode of telling, meanwhile, recalls Chris Marker so insistently that the affinity invites scrutiny. The measured, elegiac delivery and restrained atmospheric sound evoke La Jetée (1962); the recurrent “She wrote,” introducing Anjalika’s letters, echoes the “He wrote” of Sans Soleil (1983). Marker's own cinema thrives on quotation and detour; what matters is what borrowing enables. In La Jetée, a woman’s brief movement within a succession of still photographs makes time palpable in a way no account of time could achieve alone. In Sans Soleil, the correspondences among images, letters and sounds are often surprising, tentative, sometimes comic. Their particular arrangement modifies the thoughts that accompany them.

Otolith I also moves among strikingly different materials: anti-war crowds, family photographs, Soviet cosmonauts, streets in Moscow, records from India and footage of bodies in simulated weightlessness. Yet differences of origin and texture do not necessarily free the images to do different things. Under the continuity of the voice and its atmosphere, they often seem to confirm relations already established verbally. During the demonstration, for example, a digital enlargement singles out a woman talking to a man beside her. The narrator attributes to her an awareness that the protest will achieve nothing. The woman’s gesture does not particularly disclose that consciousness; the enlargement attaches significance rather than discovering it. A historian may construct meaning this way, but the film provides little distance from which to question it.

The underwater passage offers a more fertile ambiguity. Its silence, partial visibility and uncertain scale permit the image and sound to create an unfamiliar environment; the later revelation of a submerged structure gives new spatial definition to a voice speaking of having lost its place. The combination is not merely illustrative. Yet the subsequent metaphor of “swimming in a new ocean” also names what the image had begun to make strange. Narration need not be absent, nor images contradict every proposition. The question is whether the images can alter the direction of thought as readily as they are recruited to accompany it.

There is, however, another reason for the film’s persistent voice. For this imagined descendant, Earth is irretrievable except through mediated traces; for Anjalika, her grandmother’s life is likewise available only in fragments, stories and gestures remembered. The consistency of the narration may be a means of holding these distances together, an act of commemoration as well as interpretation. The tension remains: Otolith I can imagine, with considerable poignancy, histories whose possibilities were transformed rather than simply exhausted. At its most suggestive, it allows images to acquire some of that unfinished life. At other moments, the voice seems to know too readily what they have to say.

Read more about

#565 Otolith 1
#106 La Jetée

    Otolith I is part of the November 2026 edition of 20/20 Vision, a monthly micro-cinema night in argos’s Black Box, a shifting line-up of video works, from shorts to features, from their archive and beyond. With only 20 chairs for 20 spectators, the audience gathers for a screening programme shaped around a topic or a filmmaker. yanco and argos collaboratively publish a monthly essay on each programme.

    20/20 Vision: Speculative Archives showcases three works from the argos collection that were produced around the year 2000, a complex, vibrant moment at the turn of the century. Each of them fully embraces the inherent subjectivity of images and archival documents. By committing to speculative storytelling, they abandon any attempt to preserve a single, definitive truth. Ranging from post-colonial science fiction to the analysis of images and power, their work offer an alternative path, one where multiple narratives exist side-by-side and diverse realities can coexist within a shared imaginative space.

    Bio Arta Barzanji

    Arta Barzanji is an Iranian filmmaker, critic, and curator based in London. His writing has appeared in Cineaste, MUBI Notebook, Metrograph Journal, and Art Monthly. He is an AHRC-funded PhD candidate at the University of Roehampton, where his research examines film criticism and dialectical thought. His curatorial projects include the ongoing Cinema-ye Azad initiative, Serge Daney and the Promise of Cinema, and Not By Lynch: The Lynchian Before and After David Lynch. His current filmmaking project is the feature documentary Unfinished: Kamran Shirdel.

    read more

    © White Cloud / 白云 (Emmanuel Van der Auwera, 2023)
    White Cloud / 白云 (Emmanuel Van der Auwera, 2023)
    article
    Read more

    White Clouds in a Dark Age

    Emmanuel Van der Auwera’s White Cloud / 白云

    Ive Stevenheydens
    28.07.2025

    In this so-called post-truth era, the line between fact and fiction has blurred into a matter of style: what appears plausible is accepted as real. The rise of generative artificial intelligence has not merely accelerated this disintegration but formalised it. Truth is no longer something to be discovered, but something to be produced. Within this context, White Cloud / 白云 by Emmanuel Van der Auwera functions as a case study of the destabilisation of truth, image, and representation.

    Read more
    © J’ai faim, j’ai froid (Chantal Akerman, 1980)
    artikel
    Read more

    Het leven start hier en nu

    Chantal Akermans J’ai faim, j’ai froid (1984)

    Michaël Van Remoortere
    17.03.2025

    Henri Bergson geloofde dat het fenomeen genaamd humor ontstond wanneer de materiële wereld tekortdeed aan onze spirituele aspiraties. Had hij lang genoeg geleefd om het werk van Chantal Akerman te zien, dan kon hij in haar films een bewijs van zijn stelling vinden. Niet alleen was Akerman een begenadigd metteuse en scène van Chaplineske slapstick-taferelen, ook hoe zij de romantische liefde toont is, door de kloof tussen wensdroom en al te menselijke realiteit, vaak een bron van onbedaarlijk gniffelen.

    Read more
    Carnations (Martijn Van de Wiele, 2021)
    Carnations (Martijn Van de Wiele, 2021)
    essay
    Read more

    The Returning Flower

    Martijn Van de Wiele’s Carnations

    Boet Meijers
    16.11.2024

    There is a certain solemnity in this portrayal of nature: as a camera operator, Van de Wiele gets down on his knees in some of the images, filming the plants from below and letting their crowns stand out against a bright blue sky to which they stretch their fingers, as if—if left unpruned—they would continue to grow into eternity, closer and closer to their nourishing sun. A favour is done to the carnations here; framed individually, they are momentarily freed from mass production, a space in which a flower becomes the flower.

    Read more
    Katherine May Fannon (Helga Dorothea Fannon, 2025)
    Katherine May Fannon (Helga Dorothea Fannon, 2025)
    essay
    Read more

    The Amateur and the Archive

    On “Glued & Screwed #33 (Meditation)”

    Arta Barzanji
    14.09.2026

    Love and respect for an archive cannot mean approaching it so delicately that one refuses to act upon it: every selection, montage, recollection or speculation transforms what it touches. Nor does openness mean withholding commitment. It means committing strongly enough for an encounter to answer back—for an image, voice or vanished life to resist the meaning prepared for it and perhaps alter the form built around it.

    Read more
    Atopia (Olivier De Vos, 2021)
    Atopia (Olivier De Vos, 2021)
    essay
    Read more

    The Beaches of Atopia

    Olivier De Vos’s Atopia (2021)

    Ren Scateni
    20.12.2023

    Through a multilayered construction of archive materials, digitised as well as contemporary pictures, and original footage, De Vos charts their journey to the beaches of Atopia—a placeless place, brimming with both mesmerising potentiality and impossibility, a place you could be homesick for without being able to locate it exactly. As elusive as this promised land it invites viewers to, Atopia refuses easy classifications and finds a transitory place between fiction and documentary, between imagined ethnographic investigation and a research-led use of archival videos and photos to back up De Vos’s personal cognitive meanderings.

    Read more
    0.2 Milligrams of Gold (Diego Quinderé de Carvalho, 2021)
    0.2 Milligrams of Gold (Diego Quinderé de Carvalho, 2021)
    article
    Read more

    Between Forests

    Diego Quinderé de Carvalho’s 0.2 Milligrams of Gold (2021)

    Jannes Callens
    09.02.2024

    Besides a philosophical reflection on the concept of ‘lieu de mémoire’, the film is also an appeal to protect non-human phenomena in their uniqueness. The filmmaker concludes that he walks on paved forest paths because they are easier to control and more welcoming to man. Without naming it directly, this audiovisual essay touches on the Anthropocene: the era in which the earth suffers the consequences of human activity.

    Read more
    © MAGIC, A PORTRAIT OF JORIS (CHLOË DELANGHE, 2018)
    Magic, a portrait of Joris (Chloë Delanghe, 2018)
    interview
    Read more

    De ruimte die ons omringt

    Portretten van nabijheid: Chloë Delanghe’s Magic, a portrait of Joris

    Nina de Vroome
    13.01.2025

    Het fototoestel meet afstanden. Zijn brandpunt komt samen met een voorwerp in de ruimte en door de leegte rondom wordt er iets zichtbaar. Het is een vanzelfsprekende vaststelling, maar toch is deze essentie van fotografie van belang in het werk van Chloë Delanghe. Haar werk bevindt zich in een spanningsveld van intimiteit en afstand.

    Read more
    Saute ma ville (Chantal Akerman, 1968)
    Saute ma ville (Chantal Akerman, 1968)
    artikel
    Read more

    Preludes van een visionair

    Chantal Akermans La Chambre (1972) en Saute ma ville (1968)

    Inge Coolsaet
    27.05.2021

    In haar vroege kortfilms tekende Chantal Akerman, moedwillig maar ook onbewust, de contouren van haar eigen toekomst uit. Alle fundamenten van haar oeuvre, vormelijk en inhoudelijk, werden er gezet.

    Read more

    Subscribe to our monthly newsletter for updates on new releases, publications, and events!

    Subscribe

    yanco is a magazine and streaming library for short-form moving image

    kortfilm.be vzw
    Boondaalse Steenweg 249
    1050 Elsene
    BE 0478 441 315
    info@yanco.be

    with the support of the Flanders Audiovisual Fund (VAF) of the Flemish Government

    VAF
    • about
    • colophon
    • privacy policy
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn YouTube Letterboxd
    design by de Ronners
    website by eps en kaas