Skip to main content
yanco Home
Menu
  • Home
  • watch
  • magazine
  • calendar
  • index
  • Subscribe
Search Log in
  • nl
  • en
You are here
  • Home
  • Magazine
  • The List is Black
The List is Black

The List is Black

opinion by
Greg de Cuir Jr
02.02.2026

When browsing the list of the “Greatest” Short Films of All Time 2025, the usual follies persist. Only one film from outside of the Western world is in the top ten. Only two films directed by women are in the top ten, and one of them, Maya Deren, is assigned a male co-director (a credit that is not actually settled law). Eight of the top ten are either French or United States productions. The top twenty includes two more women and one film from the Global South. Of course, no Black director appears until in the vicinity of position #30.

What are we looking to replicate or reflect when we construct a list of the “greatest films of all time”? The canon is encoded in many of our educations and structures many of our discussions about film—whether we are anti-canon or not. So with exercises such as this newest effort, we are telling ourselves what we already know. More people have heard of Chris Marker, more people have seen the work of Chris Marker, because Marker’s work has circulated more, because of the structure of power in the world, because of the rules of capital, and therefore, the “greatest short film ever made” is Marker’s La Jetée. Not to overanalyse the situation, and certainly not to charge it with being a lightweight psyop, but an image of La Jetée was included in the email invitation to participate in the polling for this particular list. This is the nature of things. Certainly, La Jetée is a great film, but do we need to assign it a numerical value based on a weighted voting process? I suppose this is a rhetorical question. We live in an era where there must be a quantifiable winner, and the winner must take all.

Art has long been haunted by the nightmare of quantifiability, but film art suffers from this acutely. Because it is a young art? Because it is a mass medium? Can you imagine a list of the greatest paintings of all time? Or the greatest architectural works of all time? Even the greatest photographs of all time. Now that we are far enough into its second century, we might soon arrive at the point where it sounds just as silly to propose ranking the greatest films ever made, if only because of the sheer number of films made. And this is just one of my reservations about the task of list-making.

I have seen all of the films in the top ten on this list. In the next ten on the list, there are at least five films I have not seen or do not know very well. In the following ten, there are another five films I have not seen or even heard of. This might signify nothing other than that I am a slow cinephile. It could also be read benevolently as an invitation by respected colleagues to familiarise myself with important pre-canonical works—and I would be inclined to accept that invitation. However, I am more concerned with the assumption underlying this entire prospect.

How could I presume to submit a list of “ten greatest short films ever made” when I have not seen even half of the short films ever made? Such a prospective list would be flawed from the outset by my limited worldview. That worldview is tainted by the hegemonic powers in the film world. Let us not forget that colonial powers prevented their subjects from making films. For their viewing pleasure, these subjects were given the ‘canon’ with few alternatives. When the possibility to make films was eventually afforded to these former colonial subjects, distribution avenues became limited, as did the opportunities for translation. The playing field was always uneven, and we might argue that it still is today, even though we are flooded with the illusion of infinite choices online. Culture is wielded like hard power, and film is no exception. Film is actually incredibly effective as a form of power. This is inclusive of the very list that you are contemplating as you read this antagonistic position.

Every list resulting from such a poll should be a de facto declaration of how much we do not know, and how much we comfort ourselves by reasserting what we already know. Needless to say, there are many other Farrokhzads in need of wider visibility so that their brilliance can shine forth, but unfortunately, they must also wait out their decades in the immense shadows of the Resnaises and the Bunuels and the Snows of film history.

Greg de Cuir Jr

To be fair, there are things I like about the list. I love the implicit assumption that short film is experimental film. Documentary, narrative, and animation are underrepresented at the top end of the list, and I wonder if there is a general feeling that films that fit cleanly into these generic boundaries belong elsewhere. That said, all films were short films prior to the introduction of the feature-length format—but then, there was no such thing as a ‘short’ film. So it is a bit odd that Buster Keaton makes two appearances near the top of the list in representation of the 1920s, and no one else prior to that, save for the proto-cinematic exceptions of the Lumieres and Melies at the turn of the twentieth century. In this context, we can call Keaton an outlier, though the greatest outlier near the top of the list is Forugh Farrokhzad.

Farrokhzad is the only woman with a solo directing credit in the top ten and the only director from outside of Europe and North America in the top twenty. Her film The House is Black (1963) is a masterpiece, a brutally subversive and confrontational film with a humanist slant and a poetic soul. Such a beautifully destructive work should be welcome in any canon. It is certainly wonderful that the film was recently restored and has been shown widely in pristine form. That achievement required both cultural and financial capital, which took decades to accrue. It is very likely that ten years ago this film would not have breached the top ten, or maybe even the top fifty—which is simply to say, you don’t know what you don’t know. Every list resulting from such a poll should be a de facto declaration of how much we do not know, and how much we comfort ourselves by reasserting what we already know. Needless to say, there are many other Farrokhzads in need of wider visibility so that their brilliance can shine forth, but unfortunately, they must also wait out their decades in the immense shadows of the Resnaises and the Bunuels and the Snows of film history.

They say that men lie, women lie, numbers do not lie. But numbers do not tell a complete story either. The history of an art form cannot be reduced to numbers, and people cannot be reduced to numbers. Another devastating and brutal film follows The House is Black in the top ten: Alain Resnais’ masterpiece Night and Fog (1955) at #4. Let us note the cruel irony of assigning a number to a film about people who were assigned numbers and then exterminated. These are the stakes of the games we play. Not to say that value-driven list-making is a fascist endeavour, but it does seem low-key authoritarian. The canon will never not persist. We can imagine the end of the world before we can imagine the end of the canon. This is why I choose not to participate in reifying it in the form of a ranked list. Because we don’t know what we don’t know. But also because of what Dziga Vertov once wrote: “What’s good is not what’s really good, just that which is profitable to be considered as such.”

    Bio Greg de Cuir Jr

    Greg de Cuir Jr is the co-founder and artistic director of Kinopravda Institute in Belgrade. He has organised programmes for the Locarno Film Festival, Anthology Film Archives, the Austrian Film Museum, Metrograph, the Eye Filmmuseum, TIFF Cinematheque, and many other institutions. His writing has been published in Cineaste, Millennium Film Journal, Jump Cut, Found Footage Magazine, and numerous anthologies and catalogues. De Cuir was previously a selector and organiser at Alternative Film Video in Belgrade.

    read more

    © 0.2 MILLIGRAMS OF GOLD (DIEGO QUINDERÉ DE CARVALHO, 2021)
    0.2 Milligrams of Gold (Diego Quinderé de Carvalho, 2021)
    interview
    Read more

    From the Ardennes to the Amazon

    A Conversation About Eco-Activism in Cinema

    Jannes Callens
    13.01.2025

    Diego Quinderé de Carvalho’s 0.2 Milligrams of Gold and Andrés Jurado’s Yarokamena invite us to reconsider our relationship with nature, history, and the systems that shape our lives. In conversation, both filmmakers talk about their filmmaking process and the question of activism in art.

    Read more
    what else grows on the palm of your hand? (Dhiaa Biya, 2023)
    what else grows on the palm of your hand? (Dhiaa Biya, 2023)
    essay
    Read more

    Whispering Hands

    Dhiaa Biya’s what else grows on the palm of your hand? (2023)

    Bo Alfaro Decreton
    01.05.2026

    In a series of intimate, domestic scenes that interweave the present with the past, Dhiaa Biya honours the weathered hands of a (deceased) grandmother. Through repetition of the same gestures, the hands of three generations of women merge, free from any obstacles posed by the passage of time. Is there a more beautiful part of the body than the hands to reflect on in order to rekindle the extinguished connection between head and body, a characteristic of these frenzied times?

    Read more
    +6 Gain (Jorn Plucieniczak, 2019)
    +6 Gain (Jorn Plucieniczak, 2019)
    article
    Read more

    Sound Bath

    Jorn Plucieniczak’s +6 Gain (2019)

    Ben Flanagan
    20.02.2024

    Plucieniczak is searching for the spiritual in the notion of Living For The Weekend, and as it gets closer, the colours are further enveloping, pink turning to red. Strobes flicker on Martens’ bald head. His body is out of focus, camera swerving left and right; it’s full Irréversible; the music begins to swoosh in, a trance banger waiting patiently to drop. But instead, we cut into the lounge.

    Read more
    Old Child (Elettra Bisogno en Hazem Alqaddi, 2019)
    artikel
    Read more

    Rolschaatsen als verzet

    Elettra Bisogno en Hazem Alqaddi’s Old Child

    Yousra Benfquih
    26.10.2024

    In Old Child van Elettra Bisogno en Hazem Alqaddi schetsen droomachtige, onscherpe beelden de herinneringen van Hazem, die uit Gaza migreerde naar België. Halverwege de kortfilm, wanneer hij steile trappen af dendert, leren we dat Hazem een rolschaatser is. Meer dan een moment van kinderlijke vreugde middenin een stroom van complexere beelden en traumatische herinneringen die voor Hazem’s geestesoog verschijnen, symboliseert het rolschaatsen een verlangen naar beweging — in sterk contrast met de beperkingen op de bewegingsvrijheid van de Palestijnen in de context van hun koloniale bezetting.

    Read more
    Kaalkapje (Marthe Peters, 2024)
    Kaalkapje (Marthe Peters, 2024)
    artikel
    Read more

    Tedere pijn

    Marthe Peters’ Kaalkapje (2024)

    Michiel Philippaerts
    29.03.2024

    Al wat de pas afgestudeerde filmstudent Marthe Peters nodig heeft om te reflecteren op de spanningen en tegenstrijdigheden tussen het verleden en het heden, zijn verloren video-opnames uit haar jeugd. Aangevuld met nieuwe, poëtische beelden (handen die tekenen, een kat aaien, of met kaarsenvet spelen) en een doordachte voice-over, verkent Peters de littekens van een vergeten tijd uit haar leven.

    Read more
    elephantfish (Meltse Van Coillie, 2018)
    elephantfish (Meltse Van Coillie, 2018)
    essay
    Read more

    Dreaming Adrift

    Meltse Van Coillie’s elephantfish

    Mariana Hristova
    01.10.2022

    Darkness can be mysterious and scary but also mind-provoking and triggering for one’s fantasy. elephantfish, a film as unusual as its title, starts by describing an equally peculiar dream narrated by a quiet voice in the background of the black frame: an elephant in the sea greedily drinks the water as if trying to swallow it all. As the dreamer approaches the monster, it gets smaller and smaller, no bigger than a fish. Instead of turning into a Leviathan1 as the quasi-mythological premise of the tale suggests, it eventually dies, and the film itself unfolds in a hardly expected way.

    Read more
    Tukuleur (Brahim Tall, 2022)
    Tukuleur (Brahim Tall, 2022)
    artikel
    Read more

    Toucouleur

    Brahim Talls Tukuleur (2022)

    Orlando Verde
    17.04.2023

    De titel van de film speelt met de naam van een 19de-eeuws West-Afrikaans keizerrijk. Toucouleur is ook een van de namen van een volk uit wat vandaag Senegal heet. Maar Tall speelt ook bewust met de verwijzing naar ‘kleur’. Het is belangrijk dat de titel van betekenis verandert afhankelijk van de context waarin die uitgesproken wordt, want ook huidskleur krijgt in verschillende contexten een andere betekenis. Zo ook worden mensen met gemengde etniciteit vaak gezien als van hier noch van daar. Of juist van overal, maar dan anders, zoiets.

    Read more
    © Past Perfect (Jorge Jácome, 2019)
    artikel
    Read more

    Lijden in verleden tijd

    Jorge Jácome’s Past Perfect

    Bo Alfaro Decreton
    22.01.2020

    Leed neemt verschillende vormen aan. Het filmisch essay Past Perfect duwt ons, vanuit een ontreddering, kopje onder het verleden in.

    Read more

    Subscribe to our monthly newsletter for updates on new releases, publications, and events!

    Subscribe

    yanco is a magazine and streaming library for short-form moving image

    kortfilm.be vzw
    Boondaalse Steenweg 249
    1050 Elsene
    BE 0478 441 315
    info@yanco.be

    with the support of the Flanders Audiovisual Fund (VAF) of the Flemish Government

    VAF
    • about
    • colophon
    • privacy policy
    Facebook Instagram LinkedIn YouTube Letterboxd
    design by de Ronners
    website by eps en kaas